In the case of Odfjell Technology (UK) Ltd v HMRC [2025] UKFTT 28 (TC), the FTT has dismissed an appeal against a decision that the host employer provisions (HEP) applied to the Appellant, Odfjell Technology (UK) Ltd, and thus it was liable to pay secondary Class 1 NICs of of £16,764,743, plus statutory interest.
National Insurance – Secondary Class 1 National Insurance contributions – Host Employer regulation – whether on the facts Appellant provides day-to-day direction/control of employees of foreign employer – yes – whether operator also provides direction/control – no – appeal dismissed
Although the employees under consideration (Offshore Employees) were contracted to overseas companies (Offshore Employers), the FTT held that:
“Pursuant to those contracts the Offshore Employees … were directed to work to deliver the Appellant’s obligations … In doing so it was the Appellant that told each Offshore Employee through the rostering process when and where they would work. In addition, however, we also consider that despite the apparent autonomy exercised by the STP (senior tool pusher) the Appellant did direct how the personal service of the Offshore Employees was to be performed. … There is no question in our mind that these factors constitute a sufficient framework for day-to-day control sufficient to conclude that the terms of the HEP are met. … On the facts we do not consider that there was any framework of control or actual direction provided by the Operator to the Offshore Employees. Any apparent direction by way of verbal interactions between the STP and the WSL/OIM (well site leader/offshore installation manager) needed to be confirmed in writing and such instruction was to the Appellant, who had directed the STP to follow such instructions as part of the contract.”
https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/tc/2025/28
Related content from Claritax Books
The complex rules for National Insurance contributions are covered in depth in National Insurance Contributions.
