In the case of Poznic v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1298 (TC), the FTT has dismissed an appeal against a closure notice denying BADR on the disposal of shares in a company providing architectural services on the grounds that the shares sold had no voting rights.
CLOSURE NOTICE – Business Asset Disposal Relief claim – disposal of ordinary B shares in respect of a company of which the Appellant was a director and shareholder – significant control and voting rights held by another individual – statutory records standing as prima facie evidence – whether the company is a ‘personal company’ in accordance with s 1691(6) of the Taxation of Chargeable Gains Act 1992 (‘TCGA’) – whether the shares held by the Appellant rank pari passu irrespective of Companies House filings and the absence of a written resolution or minutes of a general meeting – whether the shares held by the Appellant conferred voting rights such that at the date of disposal the Appellant held at least 5% of the voting rights – s 169S(3)(b) TCGA – the Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008 SI 2008 No. 3229 – Appeal dismissed
The Appellant, who had been a director, but had resigned and at the time of the disposal was an employee, owned all of the “B” shares with the “A” shares owned by the other director, Mr Walsh. She argued that both classes of shares had equal voting rights. However, documents filed at Companies House (Form SH01 and the annual confirmation statements) stated that the “B” shares had no voting rights and Mr Walsh controlled the company. The Appellant maintained that, while the documents filed provided prima facie evidence, they were in error and did not reflect the true position as she understood it.
However, the FTT noted that “No evidence (e.g., a written resolution or minutes of a general meeting) has been provided by the Appellant” to support her position. The FTT also observed that, while a director, the Appellant had had a duty to correct any errors in the documents as submitted at Companies House but “There is no evidence before us to support a finding that the Appellant, or the Company, remedied any inaccurate filings with Companies house.”
Overall, the FTT concluded that:
“Whilst the Company register and Confirmation Statements may not be considered to be a demonstration of rights per se, it is a record of information that has been supplied by the Company and requires cogent evidence to rebut it. We have found that the Appellant has failed to rebut the conclusions which can be formed from the information filed. We have further found that the Appellant had the opportunity to rectify the record(s), and failed to do so. … we are satisfied that:
(1) The register is prima facie evidence of the class of shares held by the Appellant.
(2) There is no evidence of the Appellant exercising voting rights (such as a written resolution or minutes of a general meeting).
(3) The Confirmation Statements and SH01 show that the Appellant did not have voting rights.
(4) Any inaccurate filings were not remedied.
(5) The Appellant did not apply to rectify the records.
Accordingly, therefore, the appeal is dismissed.”
https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/tc/2026/1298
Related content from Claritax Books
Written for accountants and other tax advisers at an intermediate level, Capital Gains Tax is built firmly on a foundation of statutory rules and case law principles. It is illustrated throughout with practical examples, and most chapters include a summary of pitfalls and planning points.
