In the case of The King (on the application) of Martin & Ors v The Chancellor of the Exchequer & Ors [2026] EWHC 1123 (Admin), the Divisional Court of the King Bench’s Division of the High Court has refused an application for judicial review of the consultation made before the enactment of the reforms to APR and BPR announced in Autumn Budget 2024 and enacted in FA 2026.
The case was brought by Martin and Martin (both farmers) and Farmers and Businesses for Fair Tax Relief (an association representing farmers and business owners) against the Chancellor of the Exchequer and HMRC with The Speaker of the House of Commons as an interested party.
The claimants argued that the policy documents published at the time of the budget indicated that there would be a public consultation on the substance of the reforms before they were enacted. However, the review was ultimately limited to how the reforms would apply in relation to property held in trusts and did not invite views on the policy decision to introduce the reforms themselves. The claimants argued that the government had created a legitimate expectation that there would by a full consultation and thus had acted unlawfully by limiting its scope and that the failure to consult was unfair and unlawful.
However, the Divisional Court did not agree and refused permission as:
- There was no legitimate expectation – the policy documents did not provide the clear and ambiguous promise that the claimants argued they did, instead they contained qualifications and exceptions and offered political commitments that were not legally binding.
- The claim was out of time.
- Non-justiciability – the decision that was challenged formed part of the Budget and Finance Bill process, which falls within Parliament’s constitutional responsibility. Reviewing the scope or adequacy of consultation in that context would infringe Parliamentary privilege and the separation of powers.
https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/Admin/2026/1123.image.pdf
Related content from Claritax Books
Inheritance Tax by Michael Budden offers in-depth guidance on IHT matters involving both lifetime transfers and the death estate.
