In the case of Executors of Elborne Deceased & Ors v HMRC [2026] EWCA Civ 894, the Court of Appeal has dismissed HMRC’s appeal against the UT’s decision that a tax planning scheme that allowed Mrs Elborne to live in her property as life tenant without paying IHT on it on her death was effective (see the Claritax News story).
Sir Launcelot Henderson summarised the position as follows:
“The issue on this appeal is whether a scheme to avoid inheritance tax (“IHT”) entered into by the late Mrs Leslie Vivienne Elborne (“Mrs Elborne”) in 2003 achieved its desired objective of removing the value of her residence (the Old Rectory, Seaton, Rutland, “the Property”) from her taxable estate while enabling her to continue living there rent-free until her death on 6 January 2011. The scheme was a version of the so-called home loan scheme which, in its essentials, involved (a) the sale of the Property by its freehold owner, in the present case Mrs Elborne, for its market value to the trustees of a settlement created by her in which she had a beneficial life interest in possession (“the Life Settlement”) in exchange for a promissory note of equivalent value (“the Note”) which was issued by the trustees of the Life Settlement; (b) the subsequent assignment by Mrs Elborne of the Note by way of gift to the trustees of a second new settlement created by her under which she was excluded from all benefit but her three children had beneficial interests in possession (“the Family Settlement”); and (c) her continued residence in the Property rent-free until her death, which it was hoped would, and did in fact, occur more than seven years after the assignment of the Note.
By these relatively simple means, it was intended that, on Mrs Elborne’s death, the Property would be deemed to form part of her estate because of her interest in possession in the Life Settlement, but its value would be matched by a corresponding deduction for the outstanding liability due under the Note, while the potentially exempt transfer (“PET”) under section 3A of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984 (“IHTA 1984″) which she had admittedly made when the Note was assigned to the Family Settlement trustees would be exempt from charge because she had survived the making of the PET by seven years.”
HMRC had challenged the arrangement on a number of grounds. The FTT had rejected all but one of these “but upheld their contention that, in valuing Mrs Elborne’s estate immediately before her death, a deduction for the liability under the Note was prohibited by section 103 of the Finance Act 1986 (“FA 1986″) with the consequence that the value of that liability should be abated to nil”. As a result, the planning failed. This was challenged at the UT, which allowed the appeal, judging that the deduction for the liability under the Note was allowed and the planning was effective. HMRC then appealed to the Court of Appeal on ten grounds, which the Court of Appeal grouped into four bundles:
- Grounds 1 to 3 challenged the UT’s decision on the abatement pursuant to section 103 of FA 1986 (“the section 103 abatement issue”).
- Grounds 4 to 6 argued that the Note itself was comprised in Mrs Elborne’s estate as “property subject to a reservation” under section 102 of FA 1986 (“the section 102 reservation of benefit in the Note issue”).
- Ground 7 argued that, alternatively, the UT should have applied case law principles to hold that the liability under the Note did not reduce the value of Mrs Elborne’s estate under sections 5(3) or 49(1) IHTA 1984.
- Grounds 8-10 alleged in various ways that the Property was “property subject to a reservation” under section 102 of FA 1986 and certain related provisions (“the reservation of benefit in the Property issues”).
Following a detailed analysis, Sir Launcelot Henderson judged in relation to the section 103 abatement issue that:
“I consider that the debt under the Note was not a debt incurred by Mrs Elborne within the meaning of section 103 of FA 1986, with the consequence that for this reason alone the section cannot apply in the present case.”
The other grounds of appeal were also dismissed, with Sir Launcelot Henderson concluding overall:
“For all the reasons which I have given, I would dismiss HMRC’s appeal. In simple language, I consider that the scheme worked. If that may seem to some an unexpected conclusion, I would answer that the case law on property subject to a reservation illustrates that success for the taxpayer is by no means uncommon in this arcane and difficult area of tax law: see for example Ingram and Buzzoni. In the present case, it seems to me that Mrs Elborne and her advisers succeeded in implementing an ingenious scheme which worked because it took advantage of the now historic treatment for IHT purposes of interests in possession in family settlements, and of the opportunity to separate the value of her continued residence in the Property as tenant for life from the matching liability under the Note, without falling foul of either the anti-avoidance provisions enacted in FA 1986 or the approach to construction of fiscal legislation in a tax-avoidance context as explained by the highest courts from Ramsay to Rossendale and beyond.
It is also relevant to note that the transactions in the present case took place before the enactment of legislation about the disclosure to HMRC of tax-avoidance schemes under the DOTAS provisions which date back to the Finance Act 2004, and before the introduction of a general anti-abuse rule, or GAAR, in the Finance Act 2013 which, had it been in place at the relevant time, could in principle have been deployed to counteract schemes of the present type.”
https://www.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWCA/Civ/2026/894.html
Related content from Claritax Books
Inheritance Tax by Michael Budden offers in-depth guidance on IHT matters involving both lifetime transfers and the death estate.
