• Home
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
  • Resources
  • Books
  • About
  • Contact
Claritax News
  • Home
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
  • Resources
  • Books
  • About
  • Contact
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
Claritax News

IHT – references to “individual” and “life” did not preclude corporate settlor from secondary liability to ten-year charge – Lexgreen Services Ltd

04 Aug 2026

In the case of Lexgreen services Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKUT 289 (TCC), the UT has dismissed an appeal against the FTT’s judgment (see the Claritax News story) that the provisions of IHTA 1984, s. 201(d) (which impose a secondary liability on the settlor of the trust in respect of the ten-year IHT charge when this has not been paid by the trustees who are not resident in the UK) applied to a corporate settlor.

INHERITANCE TAX –secondary liability of settlor for inheritance tax under section 201 Inheritance Tax Act 1984 where a chargeable transfer is made “during the life of the settlor” – whether this includes a corporate settlor – yes – appeal dismissed

A new argument was introduced before the UT. IHTA 1984, s. 2(1) describes a “chargeable transfer” as “a transfer of value which is made by an individual”. As such, Mr Armstrong, the company’s director, argued that the ten-year charge could not apply to a company, as it was not an individual. However, the UT did not agree. It observed that IHTA 1984 consisted of two different sets of provisions, being the main charging provisions and the special charging provisions. Settled property in which there is no qualifying interest in possession is dealt with under the special charging provisions. Analysing the legislation, the UT concluded that:

“a transfer of value is treated as arising under the special charging provisions by section 3(4), which states:

…references in this Act to a transfer of value made, or made by any person, include references to events on the happening of which tax is chargeable as if a transfer of value had been made, or, as the case may be, had been made by that person; and ‘transferor’ shall be construed accordingly.

This approach by the drafter has the result that an event which gives rise to a tax charge under the special charging provisions is not restricted by the terms of section 2(1) at all. It is the occurrence of the relevant event which is treated as the making of a chargeable transfer, even though no person may have ‘made’ any transfer in a real-world sense. That is the effect of section 2(3) when it says that ‘references in this Act to chargeable transfers…shall be construed as including references to occasions on which tax is chargeable under Chapter III of Part III’, the occurrence of a ten-year charge being an occasion on which tax is chargeable under Chapter III of Part III. So, the occurrence of a ten-year periodic charge is treated as the making of a chargeable transfer, and any reference to the ‘making’ of a chargeable transfer is specified by subsection (3) to include the ‘occurrence’ of the ten-year charge. Therefore, it is irrelevant whether it is a ‘transfer of value which is made’ or whether it is ‘made by an individual’ within subsection (1), because those concepts apply only to the main charging provisions, as we have described above.”

The UT then turned to the expression “during the life of the settlor”. The issue here, which the FTT had judged on, was whether the use of the word “life” precluded a company, the Appellant arguing that as the company was not alive, it could not have a life, meaning that it was not intended that the provision should apply to a company. However, once more the UT did not agree.

Noting that “the real issue in this appeal is whether the reference to the ‘life’ of the settlor in this specific provision evidences a sufficient contrary intention to implicitly restrict the reference to settlors to individuals” the UT took a purposive approach and analysed the position as follows:

“The purpose of the periodic charge in section 64 is, broadly, to restrict the loss of IHT by the use of discretionary trusts. …

… The purpose of section 201(1)(d) is as a fallback enforcement mechanism, providing a means for HMRC to collect IHT where a liability to IHT has arisen but the tax has not been paid by the trustee. The restrictions imposed on subsection (1)(d) mean its ambit is narrowly focussed: a secondary liability arises only during the life of the settlor and, importantly, only when the trustees are not for the time being resident in the UK (when enforcement of the liability would clearly be problematic). …

… Construing the phrase ‘during the life of the settlor’ with this context and purpose in mind strongly points towards a broader reading of the words used. That broader reading would include a corporate settlor. The purpose of the provision is not, for example, to impose a primary liability to IHT on any settlor of a settlement, but rather to avoid a loss of IHT, in specified and limited circumstances, where the liability has arisen but has not been paid by the trustee …

… In such circumstances, we consider it likely that Parliament would not have intended HMRC’s fallback right of secondary recovery to be narrow. In particular, we see no reason why the Parliamentary drafter would have intended to limit that right of recovery to a settlor who is an individual, increasing the risk of non-collection of tax which has fallen due but gone unpaid—as it has in this appeal.

The drafter of section 201(1)(d) must be assumed to have had in mind that the definition of ‘settlor’ in section 44(1) refers to ‘any person’ and that a ‘person’ would include a company unless a contrary intention appeared. Against that backdrop, our preferred construction is supported by the fact that in both section 201(4) (‘where more than one person is a settlor’) and section 204(6) (‘where a person is liable for any tax’), the drafter has not chosen to limit the scope of section 201(1)(d) by, for example, referring to ‘a person who is an individual’. “

The UT therefore concluded that:

“we consider that section 201(1)(d) applies to a settlor such as Lexgreen which is a body corporate.”

https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukut/tcc/2026/289

Related content from Claritax Books

This substantial volume on Financial Planning with Trusts, jointly written by John Woolley and Marcia Banner, looks at a wide range of topical tax and financial planning strategies using trusts. The book includes CGT, income tax and IHT.

Examples of the topics covered include (among many others) lifetime IHT planning; family investment companies as alternatives to trusts; offshore trusts; trusts and deeds of variation; trustee investment strategies; death benefits under registered pension schemes; by-pass trusts; asset protection trusts; personal injury trusts; money laundering and the Trust Registration Service.

Financial Planning with Trusts

Latest articles (all topics)

  • Failure to report and account for tax on director’s loan – could question of whether error was deliberate be heard as a preliminary issue? – Edenshire Jewellery and & Watches Ltd (in liquidation) & Anor
  • Simple assessment – FTT had no jurisdiction – HMRC yet to make an appealable decision – FTT could not direct them to make one – Palmer-Cowell
  • Zero rating medicines supplied free of charge – HMRC update VAT Notice 1004
  • Costs application dismissed – HMRC did not act unreasonably – Hoodeh
Read more

Weekly email alerts

Sign up here for this free service.

wide banner

Recent Posts

  • Failure to report and account for tax on director’s loan – could question of whether error was deliberate be heard as a preliminary issue? – Edenshire Jewellery and & Watches Ltd (in liquidation) & Anor
  • Simple assessment – FTT had no jurisdiction – HMRC yet to make an appealable decision – FTT could not direct them to make one – Palmer-Cowell
  • Zero rating medicines supplied free of charge – HMRC update VAT Notice 1004
  • Costs application dismissed – HMRC did not act unreasonably – Hoodeh
  • HMRC refusal to refund VAT to customer charged in error by supplier – appeal struck out – FTT had no jurisdiction – Education Training Collective Ltd

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

©2026 All Rights Reserved

Terms & Conditions | Privacy

Copy