In the case of Henry v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 921 (TC), the FTT has dismissed an appeal against HMRC’s refusal to allow a claim for SDLT multiple dwellings relief.
Stamp duty land tax ––multiple dwellings relief ––appeal dismissed
The Appellant argued that, at the time of purchase, the property was configured as two separate dwellings as a the vendor had had a live-in carer. The property had been subsequently demolished and the submitted floor plan, which supported the MDR claim, was at variance to the floor plan on the estate agent’s marketing material. Photographs submitted to support the claim were inconclusive. The FTT judged that:
“Considering the evidence cumulatively and applying the burden and standard of proof identified above, we are not satisfied that the Appellant has established, on the balance of probabilities, that the Property physically existed in the configuration depicted by the Appellant Floorplan at the effective date.
In reaching that conclusion,we place weight on the following matters:
(1) The Appellant’s case depended heavily upon the proposition that substantial additional facilities existed within the Property at the relevant date, including an additional kitchen, an additional bathroom, and accommodation capable of constituting a separate dwelling. However, the documentary and photographic evidence produced in support of that proposition was limited and, in several respects, inconclusive.
(2) The Appellant was aware, at the time of purchase and prior to demolition, that a claim for MDR would be advanced and that the physical layout of the Property would likely be central to any dispute. In circumstances where the Property was subsequently demolished, thereby permanently removing the opportunity for later inspection, the absence of fuller contemporaneous evidence materially reduces the weight we are able to attach to the Appellant’s account. …
… (4) We also place weight on the limitations of the photographic evidence identified above. While the photographs demonstrated the existence of certain domestic features within the Property, they did not satisfactorily establish the location, configuration, or degree of separation of the alleged subsidiary accommodation within the Property as a whole. ….
… We accept Mr Henry’s submission that the layout of the Property and its capacity for use as two separate dwellings are the central and most significant considerations within the multi-factorial assessment. Therefore, in light of our finding of fact that the Property did not, on the balance of probabilities, reflect the Appellant Floorplan at the effective date of the transaction, it is unnecessary for us to undertake an exhaustive consideration of the remaining factors.”
Despite declaring further evaluation unnecessary, for completeness the FTT did briefly consider the other factors and concluded that:
“Taking those matters together, we would have had substantial doubt that the alleged subsidiary accommodation satisfied the objective test in Fiander.”
https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/tc/2026/921
Related content from Claritax Books
Stamp Duty Land Tax is a well-written, user-friendly guide to the complexities of SDLT, written for accountants, solicitors and other tax professionals, with plenty of worked examples. Topics covered include basic principles, leasehold transactions, partnerships, trusts, reliefs, anti-avoidance legislation and recent tribunal decisions. Full reference is made throughout to relevant legislation, case law and guidance from HMRC.
