• Home
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
  • Resources
  • Books
  • About
  • Contact
Claritax News
  • Home
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
  • Resources
  • Books
  • About
  • Contact
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
Claritax News

SDLT – MDR – pool house did not have sufficient privacy to be a single dwelling – Smith

01 Oct 2026

In the case of Smith v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1351 (TC), the FTT has dismissed an appeal against an HMRC decision to deny multiple dwellings relief (MDR) on the acquisition of a Main House (“Huntbourne”) with a detached Annex (“the pool house”) in its grounds.

STAMP DUTY LAND TAX — Multiple Dwellings Relief (FA 2003 Sch 6B) — Entitlement to claim relief — pool house — terms of occupancy — Suitable for use as a single dwelling — appeal dismissed

The Annex was a separate building by an outdoor swimming pool over 200 feet away from the Main House. The Main House and the Annexe were separated by a stream (with a bridge crossing). At least during the period where the trees have leaves there were trees obscuring each from view of the other.

The FTT applied the multi-factorial assessment from Fiander to determine whether the Annex was suitable for use as a single dwelling. It rejected HMRC’s argument that there was insufficient room in the main kitchen/reception room to install a bed and entertain guests there and also HMRC’s argument that there was insufficient storage for personal effects. However, it agreed with HMRC that there was insufficient privacy and security for it to be a single dwelling. The FTT rejected an argument that occupants of the pool house could have exclusive access to the pool noting that:

“Huntbourne is an impressive property and whilst we accept that some occupants of the Main House may be prepared to give up access to the pool (a significant amenity) we are not satisfied on what is before us that this proposal is objectively realistic.”

Assuming therefore that both occupants of the Main House and the pool house would be using the pool, the FTT concluded that if occupants of the main house were not allowed to access the pool house when using the pool:

“this arrangement would have the striking feature that occupiers of the Main House would need to walk over 200 feet to and from the pool in their swimwear both before and after swimming (or change in the open air outside the Annexe), to shower after swimming and if they wanted to go to the toilet. Our view is that in reality any shared use of the pool would involve occupiers of the Main House using the facilities, at least the shower and toilet, of the Annexe. We do not consider that this is an arrangement that would be suitable for occupiers generally and would require a particular type of occupier (eg relatives or friends). … we are not satisfied that there are objectively realistic terms under which the Annexe could be occupied without a material intrusion on an occupier’s degree of privacy and security consistent with the concept of a single dwelling.”

Overall, the FTT concluded that:

“We have considered the circumstances and factors above and on balance our conclusion applying the multifactorial test in Fiander is that, at the time of completion the Annexe did not have sufficient facilities to meet, by reference to occupiers generally, basic living needs with a degree of privacy, self-sufficiency and security consistent with the concept of a single dwelling. We rely particularly on our findings in relation to privacy and security. Therefore, our conclusion is that the time of completion the Annexe was not suitable for use as a single dwelling pursuant to paragraph 7(2)(a) Schedule 6B FA 2003 and consequently MDR is not available on this basis.”

https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/tc/2026/1351

Related content from Claritax Books

Stamp Duty Land Tax is a well-written, user-friendly guide to the complexities of SDLT, written for accountants, solicitors and other tax professionals, with plenty of worked examples. Topics covered include basic principles, leasehold transactions, partnerships, trusts, reliefs, anti-avoidance legislation and recent tribunal decisions. Full reference is made throughout to relevant legislation, case law and guidance from HMRC.

Stamp-Duty-Land-Tax

Latest articles (all topics)

  • Failure to report and account for tax on director’s loan – could question of whether error was deliberate be heard as a preliminary issue? – Edenshire Jewellery and & Watches Ltd (in liquidation) & Anor
  • Simple assessment – FTT had no jurisdiction – HMRC yet to make an appealable decision – FTT could not direct them to make one – Palmer-Cowell
  • Zero rating medicines supplied free of charge – HMRC update VAT Notice 1004
  • Costs application dismissed – HMRC did not act unreasonably – Hoodeh
Read more

Weekly email alerts

Sign up here for this free service.

wide banner

Recent Posts

  • Failure to report and account for tax on director’s loan – could question of whether error was deliberate be heard as a preliminary issue? – Edenshire Jewellery and & Watches Ltd (in liquidation) & Anor
  • Simple assessment – FTT had no jurisdiction – HMRC yet to make an appealable decision – FTT could not direct them to make one – Palmer-Cowell
  • Zero rating medicines supplied free of charge – HMRC update VAT Notice 1004
  • Costs application dismissed – HMRC did not act unreasonably – Hoodeh
  • HMRC refusal to refund VAT to customer charged in error by supplier – appeal struck out – FTT had no jurisdiction – Education Training Collective Ltd

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

©2026 All Rights Reserved

Terms & Conditions | Privacy

Copy