In the case of HMRC v British Airways plc [2026] UKUT 366 (TCC), the UT has dismissed an appeal by HMRC against the previously unpublished FTT decision that hotel accommodation provided at London Heathrow (LHR) for cabin crews operating “back-to-back” (B2B) transatlantic rotations through LHR was not subject to income tax or NICs because a corresponding deduction from earnings was available for the employees.
NATIONAL INSURANCE CONTRIBUTIONS – INCOME TAX – provision of accommodation to flight crew at home base during “back-to-back” rotations – whether expense deductible under section 337 Income Tax (Earnings and Pensions) Act 2003 – yes – appeal dismissed
British Airways plc (BA) had accepted that the accommodation was a benefit in kind for earlier years as the cabin crew had not been required to use the accommodation. However, following the enacting of the EASA FTL Regulations in February 2016 use of the accommodation became mandatory for cabin crew during a B2B rotation “to rest and ensure that they could compliantly commence” the second outbound flight and, as such, BA argued that the provision of the LHR accommodation was no longer a benefit in kind because the staff on B2B rotations were required to use the LHR accommodation.
The FTT had judged that deduction was available for the cost of the accommodation under ITEPA 2003, s. 337 (“travel in the performance of duties”) or alternatively under s. 336 (“amount is incurred wholly, exclusively and necessarily in the performance of the duties of the employment”) or s.338 (“travel for necessary attendance”).
The UT considered HMRC’s following three grounds of appeal that related to the s. 337 decision.
Ground 1
This was that the FTT had erred in holding that the expense of providing accommodation at LHR between the first and second transatlantic trips (of a B2B rotation) was an expense incurred “in the performance of the duties”. The UT agreed with the FTT that “The obligation to stay at the accommodation was not a collateral requirement; it was not a personal or social obligation; it was not preparatory to performing the duties of employment. It was one of them.” Dismissing the ground of appeal, the UT concluded that:
“We see no relevant distinction between the provision of the LHR accommodation and the provision of accommodation when the cabin crew are abroad. In both cases, the accommodation is provided because the cabin crew cannot ‘go home’; in one case, because the duties of their employment require them to be abroad, and, in the other because their contractual and regulatory obligations require it. But, in both cases, the cabin crew are unable to use any other accommodation that may be available to them in the UK because they are doing their jobs elsewhere. “
Ground 2
This was that the FTT erred in concluding that the expense of providing the accommodation was incurred by the cabin crew “on travelling” in the performance of the duties of their employment. Again, the UT dismissed the ground judging that:
“We agree with Mr Vallat KC that the question of whether the cabin crew are travelling for the purposes of section 337 falls to be determined by reference to the underlying facts and not the treatment for regulatory purposes. The FTT’s reliance on the regulatory position was an error of law.
If we turn to the facts as found by the FTT, we conclude, however, that the cabin crew were travelling for the purposes of section 337 ITEPA when they were staying at the LHR accommodation and that the expenditure on the accommodation was therefore incurred on ‘travelling’ for the purposes of section 337. …
… When they are rostered on a B2B rotation, the entire rotation is the job. It is also the journey. The journey does not end because of a stopover in New York or because of a stopover in LHR. The job and the journey do not end until the rotation is completed. It is only when the rotation is completed that the cabin crew are free from all duties of employment and can go home. “
Ground 3
This was that the FTT erred in concluding that the expense of providing the LHR accommodation was “necessarily incurred”. The UT dismissed this ground judging that:
“the obligation on cabin crew flying those B2B rotations to stay at the LHR accommodation became a duty of that employment, framed as it was by the commercial choices that BA had made. The question is whether the expense incurred in performing that duty was necessarily incurred. The FTT found that it was. We agree.”
As the UT had judged that the deduction was allowable under s. 337, it declined to consider the other two grounds of appeal, which challenged the FTT’s conclusions on the availability of a deduction under s. 336 or 338.
https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukut/tcc/2026/366
Related content from Claritax Books
The complex rules for National Insurance contributions are covered in depth in National Insurance Contributions.
