In the case of Oscroft & Ors [2026] UKFTT 251 (TC), the FTT has agreed that, following a capital reduction scheme, HMRC were correct to treat a subsidiary’s reserves as assets available to the parent when calculating counteraction notices under the transactions in securities regime. However, the FTT allowed the appeal as it agreed with the Appellants that the assessments were out of time.
INCOME TAX – transactions in securities regime – whether distributable reserves of a wholly owned subsidiary were assets available to the parent – yes – whether s698 provides a six year time limit for raising an assessment to make an adjustment under the regime – no – appeal upheld
HMRC had argued, when assessing “relevant consideration” for the purposes of ITA 2007, s. 685(2), that the distributable reserves of the company’s (WMGH) wholly owned subsidiary, WMF, should be taken into account as part of the assets available for distribution by WMGH. The Appellants disagreed, arguing instead that the legislation is focussed on the distributable reserves of the company directly involved in the relevant transaction in securities: in this case, WMGH. Considering the matter, the FTT concluded that:
“Taking into account the decision in Project Blue and the approach to be taken, I do not consider that it is appropriate to interpret ‘assets which are available to’ in the way contended for by the Appellants. The word ‘available’ is, in my view, wide enough to encompass assets which the company controls such that it can, in effect, ‘gather in’ those assets as it chooses.
In this case, I agree with HMRC’s contentions regarding the interaction of the Articles of Association of WMF and the Duomatic principle: the distributable reserves of WMF were amounts which were available to WMGH at the time of the transaction. The fact that WMGH would have had to resolve, as sole shareholder of WMF, that a dividend to be paid to it and also resolve to waive the restriction in regulation 102 does not mean that these were not assets available to it. Those actions were entirely within WMGH’s control without a third party’s involvement and so, in my view, the distributable reserves of WMF were amounts available to WMGH for distribution by way of dividend. …
… Accordingly, I find that the ‘relevant consideration’ in this context could, and in these circumstances did, encompass the distributable reserves of a wholly owned subsidiary.”
However, the FTT allowed the appeal as it agreed that the assessments had been made out of time. HMRC argued that ITA 2007, s. 698(5) was a freestanding power to assess that set the time limit for raising an assessment in respect of transactions in securities as six years, whereas the Appellants argued that subclause was simply a cap on the time limit provisions set out in TMA 1970, and thus the time limit for raising the assessment was the ordinary time limit of four years imposed by TMA 1970, s. 34(1), s. 698(5) being a restrictive rather than permissive long-stop cap on the time limit for assessment. HMRC argued that the regime was self-contained, whereas the Appellants argued that it was subsidiary to the existing legislation. Considering the matter, the FTT concluded that:
“it is clear that the transactions in securities regime, via s698 imposes a duty on HMRC to make an adjustment to counteract a tax advantage and requires HMRC to use one of a range of existing powers set out elsewhere in statute in order to make that adjustment: the effect is that the regime gives HMRC the power to use an existing power in circumstances where it would otherwise not be able to do so. The regime is therefore clearly not self-contained. … the regime does not create a new power to raise an assessment. It enables the existing power to raise an assessment to be used in circumstances where it would otherwise not be available to HMRC. … Accordingly, as s698 does not create a new assessment power but only create a new power to use the existing assessment powers, in my view this means that the procedural framework of those existing powers in the provisions of TMA 1970 including the time limits provisions, will apply to the making of an adjustment which is an assessment. …
… I there conclude that s698(7) does not prohibit the application of the usual time limits for raising an assessment. As it is not disputed that the assessments were raised outside the usual time limits for making an assessment, I find that the assessments were raised out of time and so were not validly raised.”
