• Home
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
  • Resources
  • Books
  • About
  • Contact
Claritax News
  • Home
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
  • Resources
  • Books
  • About
  • Contact
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
Claritax News

HMRC statement of account was not an appealable decision – no appeal permitted against interest on late paid tax – appeal struck out – Ghani

14 Oct 2026

In the case of Ghani v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1410 (TC), the FTT has struck out an appeal because there was no appealable decision to be appealed.

STRIKE OUT APPLICATION– multiple appeals to HMRC – appeal to Tribunal before HMRC decision made – whether HMRC made an appealable decision on any of the appeals – whether Appellant can still appeal to the Tribunal

Mrs Ghani had been locked out of her self-assessment account and thus her tax had instead been collected via PAYE. An underpayment had arisen and interest on late paid tax was charged. Mrs Ghani attempted to make what she believed was a late appeal, but this was not late as no appeal was possible as the statement showing the underpayment was not a decision of HMRC and thus was not an appealable decision. Also, interest on unpaid tax is statutory, and no appeal may be made in relation to interest in any event.

The FTT concluded that:

“It is clear that when Mrs Ghani appealed to the Tribunal she had no appealable decision from HMRC. The Statement of Account was not a decision at all, and it related to the amount of tax due (which was subsequently paid) and interest on it (which is not appealable).

Mrs Ghani did appeal to HMRC on 30 April 2025, but about the wrong things, so it is Rule 20 which is in point, rather than section 49D TMA.

In any event, I agree with HMRC that the Notice of Appeal of 16 June 2025 does not relate to an appealable decision, so the Tribunal has no jurisdiction to hear the appeal.

For the reasons set out above, I allow HMRC’s strike out application and direct that the appeal of 16 June 2025 shall be struck out.”

Although not part of the decision, the FTT noted that the late payment penalty, which she had not appealed, was an appealable decision, however the appeal deadline for that had now passed, so Mrs Ghani should consider whether to apply for permission to make a late appeal.

https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/tc/2026/1410

Related content from Claritax Books

In Tax Appeals – Law and Practice at the FTT, tax barrister Keith Gordon analyses some 500 precedents to show how the FTT rules are applied in practice, and how taxpayers may use the tribunal system for appealing against tax decisions.

Tax Appeals

Latest articles (all topics)

  • Failure to report and account for tax on director’s loan – could question of whether error was deliberate be heard as a preliminary issue? – Edenshire Jewellery and & Watches Ltd (in liquidation) & Anor
  • Simple assessment – FTT had no jurisdiction – HMRC yet to make an appealable decision – FTT could not direct them to make one – Palmer-Cowell
  • Zero rating medicines supplied free of charge – HMRC update VAT Notice 1004
  • Costs application dismissed – HMRC did not act unreasonably – Hoodeh
Read more

Weekly email alerts

Sign up here for this free service.

wide banner

Recent Posts

  • Failure to report and account for tax on director’s loan – could question of whether error was deliberate be heard as a preliminary issue? – Edenshire Jewellery and & Watches Ltd (in liquidation) & Anor
  • Simple assessment – FTT had no jurisdiction – HMRC yet to make an appealable decision – FTT could not direct them to make one – Palmer-Cowell
  • Zero rating medicines supplied free of charge – HMRC update VAT Notice 1004
  • Costs application dismissed – HMRC did not act unreasonably – Hoodeh
  • HMRC refusal to refund VAT to customer charged in error by supplier – appeal struck out – FTT had no jurisdiction – Education Training Collective Ltd

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

©2026 All Rights Reserved

Terms & Conditions | Privacy

Copy