In the case of Apricot Umbrella Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1254 (TC), the FTT has refused an application by HMRC to strike out the appeal pursuant to Rule 8(3)(c) of the Tribunal Procedure (First-tier Tribunal) (Tax Chamber) Rules 2009 (“Rule 8(3)(c)”) on the ground that the Appellant’s case had no reasonable prospect of success.
VAT assessments – Rule 8(3)(c) – strike out application – no reasonable prospect of success – inconsistent factual case – changing description of business activities – disputed questions of fact – output tax – input tax – burden of proof – Fairford Group plc – FS Commercial Ltd – application refused
The company had appealed HMRC’s decisions to charge VAT on certain transactions, which the Appellant argued were outside the scope of VAT, and to disallow input VAT. During ongoing correspondence the Appellant had provided different and contradictory explanations as to the nature of its business and had admitted in an email of March 2026 that information previously supplied to HMRC and the tribunal was inaccurate, revealing a material change in the Appellant’s understanding of its own business activities. The Appellant had also supplied HMRC with irrelevant documents.
HMRC contended that, despite repeated requests for information and repeated directions of the tribunal, the Appellant had failed to identify a coherent factual and legal basis upon which the assessments could be challenged.
The FTT agreed that the Appellant’s case had changed over time, however it noted that this did not mean that the Appellant had failed to identify any case at all. The relevant question was whether there was an identifiable case capable of succeeding. It was clear that the Appellant was disputing that input tax should be disallowed and that output tax should be charged. The FTT therefore judged that:
“Those contentions may ultimately succeed or fail. They are nonetheless capable of being understood and answered. HMRC’s own detailed analyses of the output tax and input tax material demonstrate that HMRC is able to identify and respond to the issues in dispute, notwithstanding HMRC’s submission that the Appellant’s evidence is inadequate. … We therefore reject HMRC’s submission that the Appellant has failed to identify a case. The real issue is whether the case now advanced is so weak, inconsistent or unsupported that it has no realistic prospect of success.”
Considering the acknowledgment of errors in the email, the FTT noted that:
“It raises obvious questions regarding reliability, credibility and the weight to be attached to the Appellant’s evidence.
However, the email does not amount to a concession that the assessments are correct. Nor does it amount to an abandonment of the appeal.
Its significance lies in the evidential difficulties it creates for the Appellant, not in demonstrating that the appeal is necessarily doomed to fail. …
… HMRC’s submissions are strongest as a criticism of the reliability of the Appellant’s evidence. They are less persuasive as demonstrating that the appeal is bound to fail regardless of what evidence may ultimately be accepted.
We therefore regard the inconsistencies as highly relevant to the eventual determination of the appeal, but not as sufficient to justify strike out under Rule 8(3)(c).”
Considering the input and output VAT appeals, the FTT concluded that:
“HMRC’s criticisms are serious and largely justified. The Appellant’s case has shifted significantly during the course of these proceedings and previous explanations have been acknowledged to be inaccurate. The Appellant faces substantial evidential difficulties and may ultimately fail to discharge the burden resting upon it.
However, Rule 8(3)(c) is concerned with whether an appeal is realistically capable of succeeding, not with whether it is likely to succeed.
The appeal raises disputed questions concerning the nature of the supplies made, the identity and location of customers and the extent of any entitlement to recover input tax. Resolution of those issues requires findings of fact and an assessment of the evidence.
Applying the principles in Fairford, we are not satisfied that the appeal has no realistic prospect of success. …
… HMRC’s application is refused.”
https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/tc/2026/1254
Related content from Claritax Books
In Tax Appeals – Law and Practice at the FTT, tax barrister Keith Gordon analyses some 500 precedents to show how the FTT rules are applied in practice, and how taxpayers may use the tribunal system for appealing against tax decisions.
