In the case of Pertemps Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKFTT 1253 (TC), the FTT has dismissed an appeal against VAT late payment penalties. The FTT found that there was no reasonable excuse and no special circumstances applied.
VAT – penalties – reasonable excuse – special circumstances – appeal dismissed.
The company, a large well-known and well-regarded recruitment agency, having obtained a new contract with a significant customer (SC), found itself short of cash and was thus unable to pay HMRC on time. It argued that it had a reasonable excuse as it could not have foreseen the level of increase in demand, it had acted prudently in seeking finance but had been unable to raise sufficient money to plug the gap, and that it would have damaged its business if it had prioritised paying HMRC rather than the temporary workers.
However, the FTT did not agree, finding that a responsible trader would have done more to forecast the level of trade and would not have entered into a contract forcing it to supply demand it could not finance, or to choose to supply such demand. It also considered that it was likely that the Appellant would have been aware of the potential problems earlier than stated per its witness statement but, in any case, it should have approached the bank and HMRC earlier than it did. It also noted that the company had an equal legal obligation to both HMRC and its workers. Considering Steptoe, the FTT judged that:
“In Steptoe the cash-flow problem arose from the late payment by a major customer in breach of contractual expectations. Here there was no comparable customer default. The cash-flow difficulty arose from the consequences of Pertemps’ own commercial arrangements which it had agreed to: the extended credit terms given to SC, the expanded supply of temporary workers, and the need to fund the wage bill before receiving payment. The difficulty was therefore not the result of an external failure by SC to do what it was contractually required to do. It was a direct consequence of the way in which Pertemps had chosen, or agreed, to conduct and expand its business with SC.”
The FTT concluded that:
“We therefore find that the real reason for the default was an insufficiency of funds. That insufficiency was not attributable to events outside Pertemps’ control in the relevant statutory sense … Taking all the circumstances into account, and applying the objective test in Perrin and Clean Car, we are not satisfied that Pertemps had a reasonable excuse for failing to pay the VAT by the due date. It follows that it is unnecessary to consider whether any reasonable excuse ceased and whether the failure was remedied without unreasonable delay thereafter.”
The FTT agreed that HMRC were wrong in failing to consider whether any special circumstance applied. However, considering the circumstances, the FTT judged that:
“Standing back, we do not consider that the circumstances are sufficiently special to make it right to reduce the penalties. Pertemps was a substantial, experienced and long-registered VAT trader. It found itself in a difficult position, but that position arose from commercial arrangements which it had entered into or chosen to perform, and from the absence of sufficiently timely steps to secure funding or engage with HMRC. The promptness with which the VAT was ultimately paid, the absence of previous default, and the seriousness of the potential commercial consequences are all relevant matters; but, taken together, they do not outweigh the considerations pointing the other way.
We therefore decline to reduce the penalties under paragraph 13 of Schedule 26 FA 2021. Although HMRC’s decision was flawed because there was no evidence that special circumstances were considered, our own consideration of the matter leads us to conclude that no special reduction should be made.”
https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukftt/tc/2026/1253
Related content from Claritax Books
Value Added Tax, written by Ciaran McGee MA (Oxon), FCA, CTA, is an extensive volume (over 1,000 pages), written primarily for non-VAT specialist accountants and tax advisers.
