• Home
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
  • Resources
  • Books
  • About
  • Contact
Claritax News
  • Home
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
  • Resources
  • Books
  • About
  • Contact
  • Business taxes
  • Personal taxes
  • Capital taxes
  • International
  • VAT
  • Tax admin
Claritax News

VAT treatment of KFC dip pots – UT judges FTT erred in deciding a multiple supply could include a composite element – appeal allowed so legitimate expectation arguments irrelevant but UT comments on them – Queenscourt Ltd

19 May 2026

In the case of Queenscourt Ltd v HMRC [2026] UKUT 195 (TCC), the Upper Tribunal has allowed the appeal, judging that dip pots, provided as part of a KFC meal deal, were a separate supply and as such were zero-rated as cold takeaway food. The FTT had treated them as standard rated as being ancillary to the hot takeaway food included in the meal deal (see the Claritax News story). Although now irrelevant, the UT also considered the Appellant’s public law argument that, by allowing an earlier claim for zero rating, HMRC had created a reasonable expectation and thus were estopped from recovering the refund already paid.

VALUE ADDED TAX – whether dip pots supplied as part of a takeaway meal deal are a separate zero rated supply or whether they are part of a composite standard rated supply alongside the hot food in the relevant meal deal – jurisdiction of the First-tier Tribunal to consider arguments based on legitimate expectation in the context of an appeal under s 83(1)(t) Value Added Tax Act 1994 – whether HMRC precluded from recovering tax wrongly credited under s 80 Value Added Tax Act 1994 on the basis of legitimate expectation – appeal allowed

The FTT had accepted that the meal deal was a multiple supply and had agreed that a number of other components could be treated separately and zero rated (for example cookies), but it had judged that it was possible to bundle the dip pots with the hot chicken and treat those as a composite supply within the multiple supply. This was challenged by the Appellant (Ground 1(a)) which argued that if the supply was a multiple one, all components had to be treated independently. Following a detailed analysis, the UT judged that:

“For the reasons discussed above, our conclusion is that every supply (including every element in a multi-element transaction which would be a supply if provided on its own) must be regarded as distinct and independent unless it falls within one of the few exceptional cases where a derogation from that fundamental principle is permitted. Leaving aside legislative overrides (such as was seen in Talacre), these exceptions require all the elements in a single transaction to constitute a single economic supply following the principles in CPP or Levob (including a possible application of both principles to a single case, as in P in W).

Our conclusion on Ground 1(a), therefore, is that the FTT made an error of law when it concluded (at [88]) that there is no reason in principle why two or more elements of a single transaction cannot constitute a single supply whilst, at the same time, other elements of the same transaction may constitute a separate supply.”

This led to the UT’s overall conclusion that:

“It is common ground that the overall supply of a meal deal is a multiple supply, not a single composite supply. Against that background, if the FTT had correctly concluded that each element of a multiple supply must be analysed separately for VAT purposes, it could only have concluded that dip pots supplied as part of a takeaway meal deal were separate zero-rated supplies. In this case the FTT’s error is a material one; if it had not made it, the FTT would inevitably have reached the opposite conclusion.

As we have just explained, finding for Queenscourt on Ground 1(a) inevitably leads to the conclusion that dip pots supplied as part of a takeaway meal deal are separate zero-rated supplies. For that reason, we agree with Ms Brown that nothing would be gained by remitting the case to the FTT and we should re-make the FTT’s decision to reflect the outcome it would inevitably have reached had it not made this error of law.”

That was enough to settle the case in the Appellant’s favour. However, although academic, the UT considered and rejected another ground of appeal (Ground 1(b)), which was “a criticism of one aspect of the way the FTT concluded that dip pots were ancillary to the hot food supplied in a meal deal” involving the significance of the customer’s ability to acquire a dip pot separately. The UT disagreed with the Appellant’s interpretation of the FTT’s reasoning noting that “We do not read this passage as the FTT saying that choice was completely irrelevant.”

Likewise the public law argument was also academic as the UT’s judgment meant that the Appellant was entitled to keep the earlier VAT refund that HMRC had tried to recover, so there was no need to consider whether HMRC were estopped from recovering it because they had created a legitimate expectation that it could be reclaimed. Nevertheless, the UT considered the matter. It made the general observation that “there remains uncertainty as to the circumstances in which the FTT can consider arguments based on public law principles (including legitimate expectation) in the context of an appeal by a taxpayer”. The UT then addressed the FTT’s reasoning as to whether it could consider such arguments in these circumstances and concluded:

“Although Ms Brown submitted that, as the substantive legislation (section 80(4A)) is permissive not mandatory, the FTT has jurisdiction to review HMRC’s exercise of this statutory discretion, neither she nor Ms Dhanoa addressed us on the conventional purposive interpretation of the second limb of section 83(1)(t). This would not necessarily be an easy task to undertake. Given our conclusions on Ground 1(a) and Ground 2, to which we turn next, nothing turns on any conclusion we might reach on this issue, and it would be wasteful and inconsistent with the overriding objective to embark on that exercise at this stage.

Accordingly, although we agree with HMRC that in reaching its conclusions the FTT made the errors of law we have identified, we leave the question whether the FTT has jurisdiction to consider arguments based on legitimate expectation in the context of an appeal under section 83(1)(t) VATA against a recovery assessment made under section 80(4A) VATA to be considered in a case where the court has heard full submissions on the relevant statutory scheme and the issue would make a difference to the outcome.”

Finally, although it had not reached a conclusion as to whether the FTT actually had the authority to consider legitimate expectation arguments, the UT nevertheless considered the Appellant’s argument (Ground 2) that when the FTT had considered the legitimate expectation issue, “the FTT erred in law when it rejected the legitimate expectation claim because it confined its analysis of whether there had been sufficient unfairness to weighing up the financial detriment suffered by Queenscourt and failed to consider the question whether permitting HMRC to resile from its previous decision to repay the VAT was conducive to good administration or not, which is a relevant factor.” However, the UT did not agree concluding that:

“Whether we call these factors particular features of good administration in the tax context or potential good reasons for HMRC’s departure from previous rulings, ‘good administration’ does not require public authorities to honour prior undertakings in all circumstances, and the FTT correctly identified the issues that needed to be taken into account when deciding whether HMRC’s decision was so outrageously unfair that it should not be allowed to stand. It reflected those issues in its conclusion.

Ground 2 is not made out.”

https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ukut/tcc/2026/195

Related content from Claritax Books

Value Added Tax, written by Ciaran McGee MA (Oxon), FCA, CTA, is an extensive volume (over 1,000 pages), written primarily for non-VAT specialist accountants and tax advisers.

Value-Added-Tax

Latest articles (all topics)

  • Failure to report and account for tax on director’s loan – could question of whether error was deliberate be heard as a preliminary issue? – Edenshire Jewellery and & Watches Ltd (in liquidation) & Anor
  • Simple assessment – FTT had no jurisdiction – HMRC yet to make an appealable decision – FTT could not direct them to make one – Palmer-Cowell
  • Zero rating medicines supplied free of charge – HMRC update VAT Notice 1004
  • Costs application dismissed – HMRC did not act unreasonably – Hoodeh
Read more

Weekly email alerts

Sign up here for this free service.

wide banner

Recent Posts

  • Failure to report and account for tax on director’s loan – could question of whether error was deliberate be heard as a preliminary issue? – Edenshire Jewellery and & Watches Ltd (in liquidation) & Anor
  • Simple assessment – FTT had no jurisdiction – HMRC yet to make an appealable decision – FTT could not direct them to make one – Palmer-Cowell
  • Zero rating medicines supplied free of charge – HMRC update VAT Notice 1004
  • Costs application dismissed – HMRC did not act unreasonably – Hoodeh
  • HMRC refusal to refund VAT to customer charged in error by supplier – appeal struck out – FTT had no jurisdiction – Education Training Collective Ltd

Recent Comments

No comments to show.

©2026 All Rights Reserved

Terms & Conditions | Privacy

Copy